Have Brees and Rodgers dethroned Manning and Brady?

No You can take records away but a lter stardom does not wipe out or in any way affect an earlier star's performance Manning may have to retire--as the best in overall talent ever Brady may see his records broken--but not his leadership, accuracy and surmounting of the Patriots' inferior offensive lineplay in support of him Rodgers is a slightly more mobile Dan Marino; Brees is an updated Fran Tarkenton. Roll-out type quarterback. But Unitas, Jurgenson, Starr and the rest remian what they were and it's necessary to ask "what would they have done under recent conditions, rules, stadium updates, etc.If they had the benefits of what players today enjoy?

Height and weight change; football really doesn't Thanks for asking Star coming.

Peyton still holds the crown as the best QB in the NFL in my eyes. Look at how good he is, he makes a joke of a team a legitimate contender. I consider Rodgers the 2nd best QB in the NFL and I consider Brees the 3rd best then comes Brady (Unanimous MVP, who cares he's the most beloved QB by the "experts").

I think it's Thomas Edward Patrick Brady. Rodgers and Brees are good, but they are joining Brady, not "dethroning" him.As for Peyton, I think that he can still play at a high level if he can get get healthy, and I would not count him dethroned until he retires... or he does his Johnny Unitas impression.

.... no way, if he had Rodgers receivers then he would put up way bigger numbers. I have Rodgers as #3, Brady and Brees have far less to work with, but are just as impressive, if they had the packer WRs imagine what their numbers would be.

The answer is NO. Each has strengths and weakness and, as far as we know, all 4 are still playing. It's third and long with the game on the line...who would you want under center?

My vote goes to Rodgers or Manning, with Brady right behind them.

Not this season. Manning won't retire. Hopefully you don't think Rodgers will throw 45+ Tds every season.

P. S Brady will pass Marino for passing yards too.

Comparing Rodgers to Manning is comical. Manning is a god. Rodgers is a cog in the system.

Brady is #1. Ask any intelligent football fan... or better yet, turn on the tv and listen to the "experts"... You sound like a seven year old girl...

Yes, but that is nothing new. The same things have happened to Farve, Elway, Aikman, Montana, Young...Starr, Unitas...

Manning will go down as an all-time great. Brady's throne was confiscated when his team was caught cheating.

I cant really gove you an answer,but what I can give you is a way to a solution, that is you have to find the anglde that you relate to or peaks your interest. A good paper is one that people get drawn into because it reaches them ln some way.As for me WW11 to me, I think of the holocaust and the effect it had on the survivors, their families and those who stood by and did nothing until it was too late.