Should the federal government push BP aside and take over the Gulf oil spill cleanup?

I don't think so. We should do what Harry did and give them Hell! I think that this current effort to stop the leak should be their last chance.

Unless BP can stop this leak this week, I think we should nationalize the company and turn BP into GP: Government Petroleum. But blaming Obama is pure politics. It is an effort by the Republicans to get back at the Democrats for their criticism of Bush's response to Katrina.

But they are two different things. Katrina was a natural disaster that the Federal Government has the know-how and resources to deal with. While it is true that Katrina was not Bush's fault, FEMA is a government agency whose task it is to deal with hurricanes and floods.

It is their job to do so and Bush was the guy who put his buddy Brownie in charge of it. FEMA waited way to long to even respond to the disaster, which is what "Bush's Katrina" was all about. The Gulf Oil Spill is an industrial accident that the Federal Government is no way equipped to handle.

The best way to explain it is: Imagine a large apartment complex under new management, with Landlord Obama in charge. For years, the BP Fire Department has been ignoring fire hazards because the previous management, Landlord Bush, were buddies with the Fire Department and let them set their own standards. However, the fire didn't start until after Obama began collecting the rent.

When the BPFD came to fight the fire, they discovered that it was just too hard to put out because their previous assurances that a fire couldn't happen were wrong, as were their assurances that if a fire did occur, they would be able to deal with it. After waiting for the BPFD to put out the fire, the tenets begin to get upset at the landlord telling him he is not doing enough. "Why don't you fire the BPFD and take over fighting the fire yourself," Mr. FOX from apartment D demands.

Landlord Obama protests that only the Fire Department has a shot at putting out the fire because they have pump trucks and hook & ladders and all the Landlord has is a garden hose. Mr. FOX knows this of course, but he has been waiting for the chance to embarrass the new Landlord since he took over and continues to scream about "Obama's Katrina" even though the two incidents are nothing alike. When Landlord Obama criticizes the BPFD for not being able to put out the fire, some of these same tenants call him un-American for dumping on a private company and scream even louder that he is not doing enough.

This is basically the situation as it now stands. If Landlord Obama DOES kick the BPFD off the job and take over their equipment, these same tenets will scream about a management takeover. However, this is just what is needed.

What Obama has to do, if this latest effort by BP to stop the spill fails, is to Nationalize BP and put Government experts in charge, ignoring the screams of "Government Takeover" the Republicans will come up with as they did with GM, etc.. He should take over the company and draft all their scientists into the Army so they will be under Obama's orders. Harry Truman Nationalized the railroads in the 40's so their IS a precedent for it. I think it is close to the point when Obama must do this if, like I said, this latest attempt to stop the spill fails.

If he does show this kind of leadership and brings the disaster under control, he will only be doing his job. But of course either way the Republicans will criticize. If he continues to let BP handle the problem, they will continue to scream "Obama's Katrina."

If he takes control over the crisis it will be "It's a Government Takeover! Obama is a dictator! He is Hitler!"

He needs to not worry about that and do what is necessary. Either way, it is a terrible disaster. The political posturing of the Republicans gleefully taking advantage of the tragedy to score political points only adds to the crisis.

Joseph McCarthy is alive and asking silly questions on Yahoo! Answers. What a dumb question, btw.

Your government allowed BP to ignore certain safety precautions when they were drilling the site. Therefor your government should be held responsible for the cleanup. It is your country's shores that are going to be destroyed by the oil, not BP's.

So quit complaining and pointing fingers and get off your butt and get cleaning up the mess before it gets into the Gulf Stream and begins polluting other nation's shores. If my country is effected by this spill, it will not be BP that I will hold financially resposible, it will be the US and their lax regulations for drilling new oil wells.

I cant really gove you an answer,but what I can give you is a way to a solution, that is you have to find the anglde that you relate to or peaks your interest. A good paper is one that people get drawn into because it reaches them ln some way.As for me WW11 to me, I think of the holocaust and the effect it had on the survivors, their families and those who stood by and did nothing until it was too late.